High Time to Abolish Net Zero

Michael Simpson of Sheffield University did the literature review and tells it like it is in his recent paper The Scientific Case Against Net Zero: Falsifying the Greenhouse Gas Hypothesis published at Journal of Sustainable Development (2024).  Net Zero is a bad idea since its science base is wrong, and its social and economic costs are unbearable with trivial benefit.  Simpson makes both of these cases in his research findings. Excerpts in italics with my bolds and added images.

Abstract

The UK Net Zero by 2050 Policy was undemocratically adopted by the UK government in 2019. Yet the science of so-called ‘greenhouse gases’ is well known and there is no reason to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), or nitrous oxide (N2O) because absorption of radiation is logarithmic. Adding to or removing these naturally occurring gases from the atmosphere will make little difference to the temperature or the climate. Water vapor (H2O) is claimed to be a much stronger ‘greenhouse gas’ than CO2, CH4 or N2O but cannot be regulated because it occurs naturally in vast quantities.

This work explores the established science and recent developments in scientific knowledge around Net Zero with a view to making a rational recommendation for policy makers. There is little scientific evidence to support the case for Net Zero and that greenhouse gases are unlikely to contribute to a ‘climate emergency’ at current or any likely future higher concentrations.

There is a case against the adoption of Net Zero given the enormous costs associated with implementing the policy, and the fact it is unlikely to achieve reductions in average near surface global air temperature, regardless of whether Net Zero is fully implemented and adopted worldwide. Therefore, Net Zero does not pass the cost-benefit test. The recommended policy is to abandon Net Zero and do nothing about so-called ‘greenhouse gases’. [Topics are shown below with excerpted contents.]

1. Introduction

The argument for Net Zero is that the concentration of CO2 in air is increasing, some small portion of which may be due to human activities and that Net Zero will address this supposed ‘problem’. The underpinning consensus hypothesis is that the human emission of so-called ‘greenhouse gases’ will increase concentrations of these gases in the atmosphere and thereby increase the global near surface atmospheric temperature by absorbance of infrared radiation leading to catastrophic changes in the weather. This leads to the idea that global temperatures should be limited to 2°C and preferably 1.5°C to avoid catastrophic climate change (Paris Climate Agreement, 2015).

A further hypothesis is that there are tipping points in the climate system which will result in positive feedback and a runaway heating of the planet’s atmosphere may occur (Schellnhuber & Turner, 2009; Washington et al., 2009; Levermann et al., 2009; Notz & Schellnhuber, 2009; Lenton et al., 2008; Dakos et al., 2009; Archer et al., 2009). Some of these tipping point assumptions are built into faulty climate models, the outputs of which are interpreted as facts or evidence by activists and politicians. However, output from computer models is not data, evidence or fact and is controversial (Jaworowski, 2007; Bastardi, 2018; Innis, 2008: p.30; Smith, 2021; Nieboer, 2021; Craig, 2021). Only empirical scientifically established facts should be considered so that cause and effect are clear.

From the point of view of physics, the atmosphere is an almost perfect example of a stable system (Coe, et al., 2021). The climate operates with negative feedback (Le Chatelier’s Principle) as do most natural systems with many degrees of freedom (Kärner, 2007; Lindzen et al., 2001 & 2022). The ocean acts as a heat sink, effectively controlling the air temperature. Recent global average surface temperatures remain relatively stable (Easterbrook, 2016; Moran, 2015; Morano, 2021; Marohasy, 2017; Ridley, 2010) or warming very slightly from other causes (Sangster, 2018) and the increase in temperature from 1880 through 2000 is statistically indistinguishable from 0°K (Frank, 2010; Statistics Norway, 2023) and is less than predicted by climate models (Fyfe, 2013). This shows the difference between the consensus view and established facts.

The results imply that the effect of man-made CO2 emissions does not appear to be sufficiently strong to cause systematic changes in the pattern of the temperature fluctuations. In other words, our analysis indicates that with the current level of knowledge, it seems impossible to determine how much of the temperature increase is due to emissions of CO2. Dagsvik et al. 2024

The IPCC has produced six major assessment reports (AR1 to 6) and several special reports which report on a great deal of good science (Noting that the IPCC does not do any science itself but merely compiles literature reviews). The Summaries for Policy Makers (SPM) are followed by most politicians. Yet the SPM do not agree in large part with the scientific assessment by the IPCC reports and appear to exaggerate the role of CO2 and other ‘greenhouse gases’ in climate change. It appears that the SPM is written by governments and activists before  the scientific assessment is reached which is a questionable practice (Ball 2011, 2014 and 2016; Smith 2021).

Other organizations have produced reports of a similar nature and using a similar literature (e.g. Science and Public Policy Institute; The Heartland Institute; The Centre for the Study of CO2; CO2 Science; Global Warming Policy Foundation; Net Zero Watch; The Fraser Institute; CO2 Coalition) and arrived at completely different conclusions to the IPCC and the SPM (Idso et al., 2013a; Idso et al., 2013b; Idso et al., 2014; Idso et al., 2015a, 2015b; Happer, et al., 2022). There are also some web pages (e.g. Popular Technology) which list over a thousand mainstream journal papers casting doubt on the role of CO2 and other greenhouse gases as a source of climate change. For example, a recent report by the CO2 Coalition (2023) states clearly Net Zero regulations and actions are scientifically invalid because they:

  • “Fabricate data or omit data that contradict their conclusions.
  • Rely on computer models that do not work.
  • Rely on findings of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) that are government opinions, not science.
  • Omit the extraordinary social benefits of CO2 and fossil fuels.
  • Omit the disastrous consequences of reducing fossil fuels and CO2 emissions to Net Zero.
  • Reject the science that demonstrates there is no risk of catastrophic global warming caused by fossil fuels and CO2.

Net Zero, then, violates the tenets of the scientific method that for more than 300 years has underpinned the advancement of western civilization.” (CO2 Coalition, 2023; p. 1)

With such a strong scientific conviction the entire Net Zero agenda needs investigating. This paper reviews some of the important science which supports and undermines the Net Zero agenda.

2. Material Studied

A literature review was carried out on various topics related to greenhouse gases, climate change and the relevant scientific literature from the last 20 years in the areas of physics, chemistry, biology, paleoclimatology, geology etc. The method used was an evidence-based approach where several issues were critically evaluated based on fundamental knowledge of the science, emerging areas of scientific investigation and developments in scientific methods. The evidence-based approach is widely used (Green & Britten, 1998; Odom et al., 2005; Easterbrook, 2016; Pielke, 2014; IPCC, 2007a; IPCC 2007b; Field, 2012; IPCC 2014; McMillan & Shumacher, 2013).

Evidence-based research uses data to establish cause and effect relationships which are known to work and allows interventions which are therefore expected to be effective.

3. Greenhouse Gas Theory

The historical development of the greenhouse effect, early discussions and controversies are presented by Mudge (2012) and Strangeways (2011). The explanation of the greenhouse effect or greenhouse gas theory of climate change is given in the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report Working Group 1, The Physical Science Basis (IPCC, 2007, p. 946):

“Greenhouse gases effectively absorb thermal infrared radiation emitted by the Earth’s surface, by the atmosphere itself due to some gases, and by clouds. Atmospheric radiation is emitted to all sides, including downward to the Earth’s surface. Thus, greenhouse gases trap heat within the surface-troposphere system. This is called the greenhouse effect.”

This is plausible but does not necessarily lead to global warming as radiation will be emitted at longer wavelengths in other areas of the electromagnetic spectrum where greenhouse gases do not absorb radiation potentially leading to an energy balance without increase in temperature. To further complicate matters the definition continues with the explanation:

“Thermal infrared radiation in the troposphere is strongly coupled to the temperature of the atmosphere at the altitude at which it is emitted. In the troposphere, the temperature generally decreases with height. Effectively, infrared radiation emitted to space originates from an altitude with a temperature of, on average, -19°C in balance with the net incoming solar radiation, whereas the Earth’s surface is kept at a much higher temperature of, on average, +14°C. An increase in the concentration of greenhouse gases leads to an increased infrared opacity of the atmosphere, and therefore to an effective radiation into space from a higher altitude at a lower temperature. This causes a radiative forcing that leads to an enhancement of the greenhouse effect, the so-called enhanced greenhouse effect.”

This sort of statement is not comprehensible to the average person, makes no sense scientifically and is immediately falsified by recent research (Seim and Olsen, 2020; Coe etal., 2021; Lange et al., 2022, Wijngaarden & Happer, 2019, 2020, 2021(a), 2021(b), 2022, Sheahen, 2021; Gerlich & Tscheuschner, 2009; Zhong & Haigh, 2013). It also contradicts the work of Gray (2015 and 2019) and others and has been heavily criticized (Plimer, 2009; Plimer, 2017; Carter, 2010).

3.1 The Falsifications of the Greenhouse Effect

There are numerous falsifications of the greenhouse gas theory (sometimes called ‘trace gas heating theory’, see Siddons in Ball, 2011, p.19), of global warming and/or climate change (Ball, 2011; Ball, 2014; Ball, 2016; Gerlich & Tscheuschner, 2009; Hertzberg et al, 2017; Allmendinger, 2017; Blaauw, 2017; Nikolov and Zeller, 2017).

Fundamental empirically derived physical laws place limits on any changes in the atmospheric temperature unless there is some strong external force (e.g. increased or decreased solar radiation). For example, the Ideal Gas Law, the Beer-Lambert Law, heat capacities, heat conduction etc., (Atkins & de Paula, 2014; Barrow, 1973; Daniels & Alberty, 1966) all place physical limits on the amount of warming or cooling one might see in the climate system given any changes to heat from the sun or other sources.

3.1.1 The Ideal Gas Law

PV = nRT (1)

The average near-surface temperature for planetary bodies with an atmosphere calculated from the Ideal Gas Law is in excellent agreement with measured values suggesting that the greenhouse effect is very small or non-existent (Table 1). It is thought that the residual temperature difference of 33K between the Stephan-Boltzmann black body effective temperature (255K) on Earth and the measured near-surface temperature (288K) is caused by adiabatic auto-compression (Allmendinger, 2017; Robert, 2018; Holmes 2017, 2018 and 2019). An alternative view of this is given by Lindzen (2022). There is no need for the ‘greenhouse effect’ to explain the near surface atmospheric temperature of planetary bodies with atmospheric pressures above 10kPa (Holmes, 2017). The ideal gas law is robust and works for all gases.

3.1.2 Measurement of Infrared Absorption of the Earth’s Atmosphere

It is now possible to calculate the effect of ‘greenhouse gases’ on the surface atmospheric temperature by (a) using laboratory experimental methods; (b) using the Hitran database (https://hitran.org/); (c) using satellite observations of outgoing radiation compared to Stephan-Boltzmann effective black body radiation and calculated values of temperature.

The near surface temperature and change in surface temperature can be calculated. The result is that climate sensitivity to doubling concentration of CO2 is (0.5°C) including 0.06°C from CH4 and 0.08°C from N2O which is so small as to be undetectable. Most of the temperature change has already occurred and increasing CO2, CH4, N2O concentrations will not lead to significant changes in air temperatures because absorption is logarithmic (Beer-Lambert Law of attenuation) – a law of diminishing returns.

Figure 1. Delta T vs CO2 concentration

The important point here is that the Ideal Gas Law, the logarithmic absorption of radiation and the theoretical calculations by Wijngaarden & Happer (2020 and 2021), Coe et al., (2021) based on the Beer-Lambert Law and the Stephan-Boltzmann Law show that there is an upper limit to the temperature change which can occur by adding ‘greenhouse gases’ to the atmosphere if the main source of incoming radiation (the Sun) does not change over time. The upper limit is ~0.81°C.

3.1.3 Other Falsifications

Many climatologists ignore the well-established ideas of the Ideal Gas Law, Kinetic Theory of Gases and Collision Theory which explain the interaction of gases in the atmosphere (Atkins & de Paula, 2014; Salby, 2012; Tec science). For example, it is difficult for CO2 to retain heat energy (by vibration, rotation, and translation) as there are 1034 collisions between air molecules per second per cubic meter of gas at a pressure of 1 atmosphere (~101.3kPa) and on each collision, energy is exchanged leading to a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution (similar to a normal distribution) of molecular energies across all molecules in air (Tec science). The Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution has been experimentally determined (Atkins & de Paula, 2014). Thus, the major components of air (nitrogen and oxygen) retain most of the energy, cause evaporation of water vapor by heat transfer (mainly by conduction and convection) and emit radiation at longer wavelengths. The small concentration of CO2 in air (circa 420ppmv) cannot account for large changes in the climate system which have occurred in the past (Wrightstone, 2017 and 2023; Ball, 2014). Plimer (2009 and 2017) presents a great deal of geological scientific evidence which covers paleoclimatology concluding that:

“There is no such thing as the greenhouse effect. The atmosphere behaves neither as a greenhouse nor as an insulating blanket preventing heat escaping from the Earth. Competing forces of evaporation, convection, precipitation, and radiation create an energy balance in the atmosphere.” (Plimer 2009: p.364).

Ball (2014) summarizes a great deal of the geological science:

“The most fundamental assumption in the theory that human CO2 is causing global warming and climate change is that an increase in CO2 will cause an increase in temperature. The problem is that every record of any duration for any period in the history of the Earth exactly the opposite relationship occurs temperature increase precedes CO2 increase. Despite that a massive deception has developed and continues.” Ball (2014: p. 1).

This statement agrees with many other scientists working in geology, earth sciences, physics and physical chemistry as can be seen in cited references in books (Easterbrook, 2016; Wrightstone 2017 and 2023; Plimer, 2009; Plimer 2017; Ball, 2014; Ball,2011; Ball, 2016; Carter, 2010; Koutsoyiannis et al, 2023 & 2024; Hodzic, and Kennedy, 2019). Easterbrook (2016) uses the evidence-based approach to climate science and concludes that:

“Because of the absence of any physical evidence that CO2 causes global warming, the main argument for CO2 as the cause of warming rests largely on computer modelling.”  Easterbrook (2016: p.5).

The results of the models are projected far into the future (circa 80 to 100years) where uncertainties are large, but projections can be used to demonstrate unrealistic but scary scenarios (Idso et al., 2015b). The literature that is used for the IPCC reports appears to be ‘cherry picked’ to agree with their paradigms that increasing CO2 concentrations leads to warming. They ignore the vast literature in climatology, atmospheric physics, solar physics, physics, physical chemistry, geology, biology and palaeoclimatology much of which contradicts the IPCC’s assessment in the summary for policymakers (SPM).

The objective of the IPCC was to find the human causes of climate change – not to look at all the causes of climate change which would be the sensible thing to do if the science were to be used to inform policy decisions. However, there is no experimental evidence for a significant anthropogenic component to climate change (Kaupinnen and Malmi, 2019) which leaves genuine scientists and citizens concerned about the role of the IPCC.

3.1.4 Anthropogenic CO2 and the Residence time of Carbon Dioxide in Air

There is a suggestion (IPCC) that the residence time of CO2 in the atmosphere is different for anthropogenic CO2 and naturally occurring CO2. This breaks a fundamental scientific principle, the Principle of Equivalence. That is: if there is equivalence between two things, they have the same use, function, size, or value (Collins English Dictionary, online). Thus, CO2 is CO2 no matter where it comes from, and each molecule will behave physically and react chemically in the same way.

The figures above illustrate how exaggerated claims are made for CO2 based on the false assumption that CO2 resides in the atmosphere for long periods and can affect the climate. These results are enough to falsify the ideas of anthropogenic global warming caused by CO2 and shows how little human activity contributes to CO2 emissions and concentrations in air. The argument is clear, that if the fictitious greenhouse effect were real for CO2 the human contribution would have no measurable effect upon the climate in terms of global average surface temperature.

The residence time of CO2 in the atmosphere is between 3.0 and 4.1 years using the IPCC’s own data and not the supposed 100 years or 1000 years for anthropogenic CO2 suggested by the IPCC summaries for policy makers (Harde, 2017) which contravenes the Equivalence Principle (Berry, 2019).

“These results indicate that almost all of the observed change of CO2 during the industrial era followed, not from anthropogenic emission, but from changes of natural emission. The results are consistent with the observed lag of CO2 changes behind temperature changes (Humlum et al., 2013; Salby, 2013), a signature of cause and effect.” (Harde, 2017a: 25).

It is well-known that the residence time of CO2 in the atmosphere is approximately 5 years (Boehmer-Christiansen, 2007: 1124; 1137; Kikuchi, 2010). Skrable et al., (2022), show that accumulated human CO2 is 11% of CO2 in air or ~46.84ppmv based on modelling studies. Berry (2020, 2021) uses the Principle of  Equivalence (which the IPCC violates by assuming different timescales for the uptake of natural and human CO2) and agrees with Harde (2017a) that human CO2 adds about 18ppmv to the concentration in air. These are physically extremely small concentrations of CO2 which suggest most CO2 arises from natural sources. It can be concluded that the IPCC models are wrong and human CO2 will have little effect on the temperature.

4. Conclusions

Like many other researchers it was assumed there was robust science behind the greenhouse gas theory and that Net Zero was essential to achieve, but after investigation it now appears that the greenhouse gas theory is questionable and has been successfully challenged for at least 100 years (Gerlich and Tscheuschner, 2009). Much better explanations for planetary near surface atmospheric temperatures are available based on robust, empirically derived scientific laws such as the Ideal Gas law.

Better assessments of the potential increase in temperature with doubling CO2 concentrations are available and the calculated increase is small ~0.5°C (Coe et al., 2021; van Wijngaarden & Happer, 2019, 2020 and 2021; Sheahen, 2021; Schildknecht, 2020) and will remain very small with increased CO2 concentration because the infrared CO2 absorption bands are almost saturated and absorption follows the logarithmic Beer-Lambert law (Figure 1). Much of the work using the Hitran database has been tested against satellite measurements of the outgoing radiation from the Earth’s atmosphere and the calculations are in almost perfect agreement (Sheahen, 2021).

This suggests that the physicists are correct in their assessment of the likely very small increase in atmospheric temperature and therefore there is a strong case against Net Zero as it will have no discernible effect on temperature and the cost of Net Zero is huge. Therefore, the Net Zero project does not pass the cost-benefit test (Montford, 2024b; NESO, 2024). That is the costs are disproportionately high for little or no benefit. Thus, the correct response to a non-problem is to do nothing. The monies being wasted on Net Zero should be spent for the benefit of citizens (e.g. education, health care, public health, water infrastructure, waste processing, economic prosperity etc.). There are many other pressing public health problems from burning fossil fuels which should be addressed (e.g. air pollution especially particulates and carbon monoxide).

Better calculations of the human contribution to atmospheric CO2 concentrations are available and it is small ~18ppmv (Skrable et al., 2022; Berry, 2020; Harde 2017a & 2017b; Harde, 2019; Harde 2014). The phase relation between temperature and CO2 concentration changes are now clearly understood; temperature increases are followed by increases in CO2 likely from outgassing from the ocean and increased biological activity (Davis , 2017; Hodzic and Kennedy, 2019; Humlum, 2013; Salby, 2012; Koutsoyiannis et al, 2023 & 2024).

“In conclusion on the basis of observational data, the climate crisis that, according to many sources, we are experiencing today, is not evident yet.” Alimonti etal. 2022: 111.

Many researchers are addressing the ‘CO2 and climate change problem’ by suggesting decarbonization and other approaches such as Net Zero. CO2 is more than likely not the temperature control and has a very minor to negligible role in global warming (The Bruges Group, 2021; De Lange and Berkhout, 2024; Manheimer, 2022; Statistics Norway 2023; Lindzen and Happer, 2024; Lindzen, et al., 2024).

The scientific literature was examined and found to provide several alternative views concerning CO2 and the need for Net Zero. The objectives of this paper have been achieved and the conclusions can be briefly summarized:

  1. CO2 is a harmless highly beneficial rare trace gas essential for all life on Earth due to photosynthesis which produces simple sugars and carbohydrates in plants and a bi-product Oxygen (O2). CO2is therefore the basis of the entire food supply chain (see Biology or Botany textbooks or House, 2013). CO2 is close to an all-time low geologically (Wrightstone, 2017 and 2023) and controls on CO2 emissions and concentrations in air should be considered as very dangerous and expensive policy indeed. Net Zero is not necessary and should be abandoned.
  2. The greenhouse gas theory has been falsified (i.e. proven wrong) from several disciplines including paleoclimatology, geology, physics, and physical chemistry. CO2 cannot affect the climate in such small concentrations (~420ppmv or ~0.04%) and basing government policy on output from faulty climate models will prove to be very expensive and achieve nothing for the environment, public health, or the climate.

“There is no atmospheric greenhouse effect, in particular CO2 greenhouse effect, in theoretical physics and engineering thermodynamics. Thus, it is illegitimate to deduce predictions which provide a consulting solution for economics and intergovernmental policy.” (Gerlich & Tscheuschner, 2009: 354).

  1. The oceans contain approximately 50 times as much CO2 as is currently present in the air (Easterbrook, 2016; Wrightstone, 2017 and 2023) and as such Henry’s Law will work to maintain the dynamic equilibrium concentration in air over the longer term as the ocean will absorb and outgas CO2(Atkins & de Paula, 2014). Net Zero will, therefore, achieve nothing for the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere. If the volcanic sources of CO2 are as Kamis (2021), the IPCC and others suggest many times the human contribution, then Net Zero will have no measurable effect on atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Net Zero should, therefore, be abandoned.
  2. The contribution to greenhouse gases, especially CO2, attributable to humans is extremely small, almost negligible (~4.3% or ~18ppmv total accumulation) and half is absorbed by the ocean and biomass. Other naturally occurring so-called greenhouse gases are present in very small/negligible quantities (e.g. CH4, N2O). The systematic attempts to eliminate these trace gases from the atmosphere by reducing industrial output, reducing farming, eliminating fossil fuel use, and changing the way human civilization lives is totally unnecessary – again the ‘do-nothing strategy’ is strongly recommended.
  3. The sciences have been largely ignored by politicians and activists. There have been numerous failings of governments to take notice of scientific findings and they have succumbed to unnecessary pressure from activist groups (including the United Nations and the IPCC). Net Zero is just one example where costly efforts by governments will achieve nothing and not address the real problems of air pollution, public health, or economic well-being of citizens.

“There is not a single fact, figure or observation that leads us to conclude that the world’s climate is in any way disturbed.” (Société de Calcul Mathématique SA, 2015:3).

  1. Circular reasoning is used by the climate modelers. That is, the fictitious greenhouse effect is built into the models such that when the parameter of CO2concentration is increased then the temperature output of the models increases, producing models which run relatively hot compared to natural variability. This reduces the so-called greenhouse effect to little more than a ‘fudge factor’ or ‘parameter’ within models which essentially gives you the answer that you set out to prove. This circular reasoning is hardly scientific enquiry and with data ‘homogenization’ and infilling of missing data begins to look rather peculiar. Climatologists need to recognize these issues, address the real reasons for climate change and offer genuine solutions to any real problems.
  2. The claim of consensus is completely unscientific in its approach (Idso et al, 2015a). Noting that 31,000 US scientists and engineers signed the petition protest (Robinson et al., 2007), recently 90 Italian scientists wrote an open letter to the Italian government (Crescenti et al., 2019), and 500 climatologists and scientists signed an open letter to the UN Secretary General (Berkhout, 2019). All explaining that CO2 is not the cause of climate change. There are thousands of academic papers and books questioning anthropogenic climate change with good data.

Many other concerned individuals have looked at the evidence for anthropogenic climate change based on CO2 and found it wanting (e.g. Davison, 2018; Rofe, 2018).

“If in fact ‘the science is settled’, it seems to be much more settled in the fact that there is no particular correlation between CO2 level and the earth’s temperature.” (Manheimer, 2022).

and

“If you assume the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change are right about everything and use only their numbers in the calculation, you will arrive at the conclusion that we should do nothing about climate change!” (Field, 2013).

The academic literature in science offers numerous and far better explanations for climate change than the fictitious greenhouse effect. Researchers should recognize this fact and start to look at dealing with the real causes of climate change. Net Zero is an enormously expensive solution to a non-problem and has no obvious redeeming features. The Net Zero policy is not financially sustainable and should be abandoned.

 

 

 

World Bank Made Stupid by Climate Mania

Tilak Doshi writes at Clintel Climate Mania Has Made the World Bank Stupid.  Excerpts below in italics with my bolds and added images.

The World Bank was founded to promote economic growth in developing
countries but has joined the brigade fulminating against the weather gods.
The world’s poor deserve better than that.

As the faithful gather in Antalya for COP31, the World Bank laid its offering on the altar last week: Governance for Climate and Development, the fifth annual digest of its Country Climate and Development Reports (CCDRs) now covering 103 economies. One might have expected a chastened institution. In April 2025 US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told the Bretton Woods twins (World Bank and IMF) that mission creep had knocked them off course, and on June 29th this year the Bank duly retired its target of steering 45% of its financing to climate. Yet its own climate page still boasts of $48 billion in “climate co-benefits” in the last fiscal year, 44% of its own-account financing.

The target is dead. The mania – a form of climate-focused pathology – lives on.

The cart before the horse

The CCDR is the Bank’s “core diagnostic” for helping countries align their “climate ambitions” with their development priorities, and the Bank’s blog trails the new report as a journey from commitment to delivery. The phrasing smuggles in an equivalence that no finance minister in Lusaka or Abuja would recognise.

Why would a poor country have climate ambitions at all,
beyond ensuring that poverty does not stand between
its citizens and the travails of bad weather?

Is civilisation itself not born of the struggle against the depredations of nature? Is science, in the Baconian tradition, not power over a harsh nature, the taming of her furies for the comfort of man? The ambitions in question belong to the Net Zero ideologues of Brussels and Davos. The poor merely get to be the guinea pigs of climate modelling and Net Zero imperatives.

The Bank’s own text gives the game away. Its modelled losses are larger in poorer and hotter economies. Its headline adaptation case is Nigeria, where the projected GDP loss shrinks from 6.7% to about 1% once one assumes mechanisation, air conditioning, health interventions and flood-resilient investment. Heat stress, it notes, costs far less in high-income countries, where machines do the heavy lifting. Mauritius is declared at risk of water scarcity, yet 61% of the water its system captures is lost before it reaches a customer. That is a plumbing problem. Mechanisation, air conditioning and pipes that do not leak used to be called economic development. The Bank has rediscovered it and filed it under “climate adaptation”.

Unsurprisingly, the Bank finds that the poor, and poor women above all, suffer most in its scenarios. Some 1.5 billion people, it says, are exposed to climate hazards and highly vulnerable because they lack basic infrastructure, financial access or social protection. Because, that is, they are poor. The rich are spared by sturdier homes and higher living standards. Poverty is the root cause of deprivation whatever the weather throws at people, and it would remain so under the most benign climate imaginable. The remedy is growth, as development economists such as Jagdish Bhagwati have argued for decades. The record bears them out: global death rates from natural disasters have fallen by more than 90% over the past century, a century in which the planet warmed and humanity grew rich enough to cope.

From the finance ministry to ‘civil society’

How did a once competent institution arrive here? The late Deepak Lal, who served as the Bank’s research administrator in the mid-1980s, saw it coming. In a 2004 column he described the battle between the “old” Bank, whose advice was grounded in the classical liberal economics summarised as the Washington Consensus, and the new one fashioned under Sir James Wolfensohn, the ninth President of the World Bank, which embraced the NGOs’ ‘civil society’ agenda.

On one side stood finance ministries and trained economists; on the other, activists, aid ministries and UN agencies. To ask the two to split the difference, Lal wrote, was like asking a scientist who knows the earth is round to accommodate a man who believes it flat. Citing the eminent economist Anne Krueger, he observed that once private capital markets had opened to developing countries the Bank faced three choices: confine itself to the poorest countries, reinvent itself around ‘soft’ issues such as the environment and NGO engagement, or close down. Bureaucrats being bureaucrats, it chose the second. Lal recommended the third.

The new report shows the NGO mind in full possession of the building at 1818 H Street in Washington, D.C. Its governance chapter does not ask how poor countries might secure small government (to reduce propensities for corruption), secure property rights, sound money or cheap energy. It celebrates “framework laws” that turn climate targets into statutory obligations and “bind successive administrations”, noting with approval that more than 50 of its 103 economies have enacted or are preparing one. It advises that where climate branding meets resistance, energy access can offer a “more consensual framing”. It looks forward to “irreversible structural change”. Voters who might prefer cheaper electricity are a political-economy constraint to be managed. Britain, which pioneered this kind of legislation, now enjoys the highest electricity prices in the industrialised world. It is an odd export to press on poorer developing countries.

The same string of terrible ideas runs through the “low-emission pathways”, which propose an average 78.7% cut in emissions by 2050 for the countries modelled. Bulgaria, where the report admits nearly 30% of households were energy-poor in 2023 and where the exit from coal threatens 12,000 jobs at Maritsa East, is nonetheless walked down a path anchored in Net Zero by 2050. The modelled bill for all this “climate-smart development” averages 1.8% of GDP a year to 2030, and 11% in Fiji. Nigeria, we learn, received climate finance equal to about 8% of its estimated annual needs. Having invented the need, the Bank laments the gap.

Back to factory settings

The remedy is not complicated. The Bank should stop producing climate diagnostics and return to asking the question its founders set it: what stands between a country and sustained economic growth? The answers have not changed since Smith. Peace, easy taxes, tolerable justice, open trade and the cheapest reliable energy available will do more to protect a Gambian farmer or a Fijian fisherman from drought and storm than any number of framework laws and budget-tagging exercises. If the Bank cannot bring itself to say so, Lal’s third option remains on the table.

How half a billion people have risen out of extreme poverty in recent decades. Underlying and enabling everything: Access to affordable, reliable energy

.

 

Antidote for Sea Level Phobia

To promote their agenda climatists like to monger fears with predictions of coastal flooding from rising sea levels.  Many have seen such warnings from UN leader Gutterres.

In the brief video below Linnea Lueken explains why not to fear sea levels rising.  For those preferring to read I provide a transcript with my bolds and some of her exhibits.

Hey everyone, this is Linnea Lueken from the Heartland Institute here with another Climate Fact Check. In this video, I’m going to talk about sea level rise and whether or not it poses an existential threat to coastal communities. Global sea level has risen more than 400 feet since the end of the last ice age, which is what sea level does as ice retreats in the period between ice ages as ice sheets decline.

This rise continues through today. Since the mid-1800s, global sea level has risen about one foot per century, or a little less than an inch per decade. There is some debate considering whether there has been a slight acceleration in sea level rise in recent decades.The present rate of rise is not nearly as dramatic as some of the doomsday claims made by the mainstream media. NASA satellite readings that date back to 1993 show that sea level is rising at a pace of just 1.2 inches every decade. Older records from tide gauges show a rate of about one foot per century, meaning that the present rate of rise is similar to what occurred in previous centuries.

This rate is hardly an existential threat. You might hear about certain locations that have a much faster or much slower or even reversed rate of sea level rise. This is true and is due to local unique conditions like tectonic plate movement, aquifer depletion that causes land sinking, and the difficulties with managing developed areas like New Orleans that sit on naturally unstable ground like river deltas, rather than climate change.As far as human contribution to sea level rise, it appears to be pretty minor. Even if we assume the modest increase in recent sea level rise is a real trend rather than a short-term variance, and even if we attribute all of the recent increase to humans, human activity is accounting for just three-tenths of an inch per decade, or three inches per century. Humans have adapted quite well to rising seas throughout the past two centuries.

Cities and towns that were on the coast in the mid-1800s remain intact on coastlines today, despite nearly two feet of sea level rise since then. And that was with only 19th and 20th century technologies available. With today’s 21st century technologies, we should be able to adapt even easier to slowly rising seas.

Rotterdam—Ninety years thriving behind dikes and dams.

That’s all I have for this fact check. For the sources used as reference for this video, you can check out climateataglance.com, where you can also download a free copy of the book Climate at a Glance for Teachers and Students. If you prefer paper, you can purchase a hard copy on Amazon. We also have an app available called Climate at a Glance for Android and iPhone. Thanks for watching.

See Also Sea Level Rise Hype from Climatists Lying by Omission Again

 

Ice Melt Flooding False Alarm

The above analysis is thorough but incomplete, and may be taken by climatists to be supporting their alarms about flooding from rising sea levels.  The author is clear that the slow steady rise would take many centuries, even presuming only future warming and ignoring future cooling.

Unaddressed is the assumption that rising CO2 is causing recent warming and sea level rise. This Clintel paper No acceleration in sea level rise detected worldwide shows that data from 200 long service tidal gauges show no acceleration in sea live rise at the coastlines.  In the modern era, sea levels are still rising, at an average rate of 1.7 ± 0.4 mm/year between 1901 and 2022 (Deltares), which disputes the IPCC climate models projections of many cms to come.

Further a discussion of earth sea levels must consider not only the false analogy of a bathtub, but also the dynamics and effects of a rotating sphere 71% covered with ocean.  Hydrologist Aftab Alam Khan published in Geoscience Frontiers  Why would sea-level rise for global warming and polar ice-melt?

Conclusion
Geophysical shape of the earth is the fundamental component of the global sea level distribution. Global warming and ice-melt, although a reality, would not contribute to sea-level rise. Gravitational attraction of the earth plays a dominant role against sea level rise. As a result of low gravity attraction in the region of equatorial bulge and high gravity attraction in the region of polar flattening, melt-water would not move from polar region to equatorial region.

Further, melt-water of the floating ice-sheets will reoccupy same volume of the displaced water by floating ice-sheets causing no sea-level rise. Arctic Ocean in the north is surrounded by the land mass thus can restrict the movement of the floating ice, while, Antarctic in the south is surrounded by open ocean thus floating ice can freely move to the north. Melting of huge volume of floating sea-ice around Antarctica not only can reoccupy volume of the displaced water but also can cool ocean-water in the region of equatorial bulge thus can prevent thermal expansion of the ocean water.

Melting of land ice in both the polar regions can substantially reduce load on the crust allowing crust to rebound elastically for isostatic balancing through uplift causing sea level to drop relatively. Palaeo-sea level rise and fall in macro-scale are related to marine transgression and regression in addition to other geologic events like converging and diverging plate tectonics, orogenic uplift of the collision margin, basin subsidence of the extensional crust, volcanic activities in the oceanic region, prograding delta buildup, ocean floor height change and sub-marine mass avalanche.

 

Lomborg: Net Zero Colossal Cost, Tiny Benefit

Bjorn Lomborg’s New York Post article is Colossal cost — and tiny benefit — of the ‘net zero’ climate madness.  Excerpts in italics with my bolds and added images.

Right now, thousands of diplomats, bureaucrats and campaigners are meeting in Türkiye yet again for the 31st United Nations climate summit.

The demand will be the one made repeatedly at previous conferences: net zero by 2050. What nobody will say is what that costs, or what it buys. In 30 summits, nobody has calculated the price versus the benefit. So I have.

I built NetZeroCostBenefit.com that lets anyone see what the United States, or any other country or group of countries, would achieve by reaching net zero in 2050, what it would cost, and what the climate benefit would be worth.

None of the inputs are mine: The climate model, MAGICC, is used throughout the UN’s own climate reports and can translate any country’s promised emissions cuts into lower temperatures by 2100. The costs come from the UN’s own surveys of economic models, and the damage estimates from the two most recent syntheses of the economics of warming.

Anyone can check the arithmetic, though few delegates in Antalya will want to.

For its latest report and updates, the climate panel gathered nearly a thousand model estimates of what climate policy costs. Almost none of them get anywhere near net zero by 2050, because it is so hard and costly. Only three models reach net zero starting from today’s actual emissions, rather than assuming cuts that began years ago.

They find that global net zero would cost between 3% and 19% of global GDP in 2050, because expensive energy throttles growth. My website uses the middle one, estimating a loss of 7.2% of GDP in 2050, measured from current policies.The benefits come from the two most recent syntheses of the damage from warming, by one of the most quoted climate economists, Richard Tol, and the other by William Nordhaus, the only climate economist to win the Nobel prize in economics. Given the warming the UN model projects under current policies, they find that climate change will cost the world 1.8% to 2.8% of GDP by 2100.

That is a real loss, but nowhere near the catastrophes bandied about. It is also a lot less than a 7.2% loss of GDP, and a lot further away. Moreover, net zero only avoids part of the damage.

Nor does one country’s effort buy much. If the United States reaches net zero in 2050 and stays there, the UN model says global temperature in 2100 would be 0.14°F lower. Nobody would notice.

Yet Americans would certainly notice the cost: by 2045 the annual cost would be $1.2 trillion a year. Over the century the cost adds up to $12.7 trillion in today’s money. The global climate benefit adds up to just under $2 trillion. The American sacrifice delivers 15 cents of benefits for every $1 spent.

Some will object that no country should look at its own numbers this way, because if everyone notices large costs but tiny benefits, nothing will get done. But a global deal that only works if nobody checks the numbers is not much of a deal. And the math doesn’t improve by pooling: the website shows that every nation ends up doing much less good for the world than what they put in.

Indeed, when you look at the whole world, global net zero by 2050 would avoid $24 trillion in climate damage this century but cost $255 trillion, both in today’s money. That’s 9 cents on the dollar.

The problem isn’t that countries act alone.
It’s that the policy itself costs more than it delivers.

Fossil fuels remain cheap and plentiful, despite price fluctuations. It is little wonder that they still supply more than four-fifths of global energy, and emissions rose again last year. At the pace of the past half-century, they won’t be gone by 2050. They’ll be gone a millennium later, in 2997.

There are much better ways to spend money than chasing “net zero,”
although most won’t be on the climate agenda at COP31.

The summit president has already made the August glacier flood in Nepal, which killed more than 1,400 people, his exhibit A: “If we want to understand the consequences of climate change, we need only look at Nepal.” Yet nothing agreed in Antalya will make the next flood measurably smaller. Early-warning systems and sturdier bridges would save far more Nepalese lives, far sooner, for far less money. Lifting people out of poverty, in Nepal and around the world, will make everyone less climate vulnerable and do far more good. None of these solutions costs anywhere near $255 trillion.

It doesn’t mean that climate change is harmless. But it means that net zero by 2050 is an egregiously bad buy. Across 30 climate summits, delegates have ignored that reality. Now anyone can run the numbers.

Bjorn Lomborg is President of the Copenhagen Consensus, Visiting Fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, and author of “False Alarm” and “Best Things First.”

Addendum:  Lomborg on the 21st century: cost-benefit analysis of climate policy

The yellow line shows the cost of climate policy (in trillions of dollars) as the limit of acceptable warming goes down. So the point at the bottom right of the graph shows that at zero policy cost, meaning if we do nothing, then according to Nordhaus’ model we will get warming of about 4.1 degrees by 2100. Whereas the upper left end of the yellow line shows that if we try to minimize warming we could get it down to about 2.2 degrees but it would cost $170 trillion doing so.

So if we go all in, we spend $170 trillion to avoid 1.8 degrees of warming.

Now to the orange line, which shows the estimated costs of the warming itself. If we keep warming to 2.2 degrees C, the models say the “social costs”, that is, the total losses humans will suffer, would be about $40 trillion, while if we get 4.1 degrees C warming the social costs will be about $140 trillion. Both figures are large, though bear in mind that they should be subtracted from what global GDP is estimated to reach in 2100, which will be enormous barring other catastrophes. But given these calculations, what should we do? From among the available policy choices, which is the best?

The key to figuring out the best option is to add the two costs together, that is, to pile the yellow line atop the orange one, which gives the black area in the chart. Its top line, unsurprisingly, drops initially as fairly cost-effective policies bring significant reductions in temperature increase, the famous picking of low-hanging fruit, and then turns back up as it gets harder and harder to reach more difficult results. And the point where it turns back up, it turns out, is at 3.5 degrees of warming, just a little below the 4 degrees we get from doing nothing. At which point we spend around $20 trillion total on climate policy.

If instead we try to stop the warming altogether, we fail, both in only holding it to 2.2° and in spending so much trying that we pile $170 trillion in policy costs atop $40 trillion in climate costs for a total bill of well over $200 trillion, which is not just worse than the optimum choice, it’s worse than doing nothing at all.

So our best bet is to prevent a bit of the warming, but only a little.
And if the models exaggerate either the warming or its costs,
that choice gets even better.

In fact Nordhaus’ model can be criticized for building in so much climate sensitivity that we get 4 C warming by 2100, which almost certainly is an overestimate. It can also be criticized for assuming politicians will implement efficient policies. Lomborg re-does the analysis under the assumption that policy costs are double the efficient level, and the result is the optimal target moves up to 3.75C, meaning we do even less.

Either way, the conclusion from a mainstream Nobel Prize-winning economic analysis based on mainstream assumptions about the science, rather than the claims of “deniers”, is that we aren’t going to stop warming no matter what we do, and that we shouldn’t try to go to Net Zero or anywhere close. Instead, most targets being talked about are worse than doing nothing, and the optimal policy path involves only modest efforts to reduce emissions over the 21st century. Which actually suggests that all those politicians talking a lot while doing very little are accidentally on the right course.

Summary:  Even taking the dubious assumption that fossil fuel CO2 causes global warming does not justify the costly attempt to reduce CO2 emissions down to net zero.

Nature Changing the World Underneath Our Feet

Humans want a right to a stable Climate? Forget about it.

For those preferring to read, a transcript from the captions is provided below with my bolds.

Nature Changing the World Under Our Feet

Africa is tearing apart. In 2025, scientists watched in real time as the ground in Ethiopia cracked open. Fissures wide enough to swallow roads and rattle villages.

This story is unfolding beneath people’s feet right now in one of the hottest, harshest landscapes on earth. And what’s driving it? A hidden force deep beneath the crust, pulsing upward like a heartbeat, its jolts recorded in seismic data collected just this year. If you’ve ever wondered what it looks like when a continent begins to split, this is it.

To understand, we need to go to East Africa. I’m Mark Watts, welcome to Deep Science. This is the Afar region, a landscape that feels almost otherworldly. Temperatures here soar above 115 degrees Fahrenheit or 45 degrees Celsius. The ground shimmers with heat and vast salt flats stretch endlessly to the horizon. In the distance, volcanoes dominate the skyline, some active, others long silent but scarred by ancient eruptions.

And then there is Erta Ale, a lava lake that has burned for decades in the heart of Afar, one of only a few like it anywhere on earth. Its surface never rests, crusts of rock form and tear apart. It is beautiful and terrifying at the same time. Few places on earth bring us this close to the living core of the planet. Yet despite its harshness, this land has shaped us, fossils of Australopithecus afarensis. Our ancient relatives were found around here.

The famous skeleton Lucy was unearthed in this very ground. In a sense, Afar is both the birthplace of humanity and the stage for earth’s next geological act. Geologists call this place a triple junction where three tectonic plates meet, the African, the Somali and the Arabian. It’s a collision of boundaries, three puzzle pieces pulling apart at once. Beneath the surface, rising heat from the mantle weakens the crust while old fractures give it places to split. Together they’ve created one of the most unstable regions on the planet.

Think of it like a wooden table that’s already been scratched and scored. Press hard enough and it will split exactly along those old weaknesses. That’s what Afar is doing. Only instead of wood, it’s entire slabs of continent cracking along ancient scars. The region is a living laboratory where we can watch in real time how continents begin to rupture.

But how does this process actually work? What forces are tugging, stretching and breaking Africa apart? The secret lies in plate tectonics, the giant slabs of earth’s crust that rest on a softer layer beneath. They drift only centimetres each year, about as fast as your fingernails grow. But over millions of years that slow motion reshapes continents. In Afar, those forces are on full display.  The land isn’t really gently easing open, it’s under tension rather, pulled in several directions at once. And like dough being stretched too far, the crust begins to thin, tear and eventually split. Only here it’s solid rock ripping apart.

The East African Rift itself has two main branches, the eastern arm running through Ethiopia and Kenya, and the western arm slicing along lakes like Tanganyika and Malawi. Each branch behaves a little differently. Some segments break dramatically with earthquakes, others leak lava more quietly. Together though they form a scar across the continent, one that is lengthening every year. And when plates stretch too quickly or unevenly, the stress can release all at once. The ground jolts, ruptures and sometimes collapses in spectacular fashion.

That leads us to a moment 20 years ago when the earth quite literally cracked open before people’s eyes. What exactly happens when the rift decides to move suddenly, not over centuries, but in just a few days? In 2005, scientists and locals in Afar got their answer. A series of earthquakes rattled the region, followed by a deep rumble from beneath the earth. Then it happened. A colossal crack tore across the desert floor. In less than two weeks the ground split open along a line nearly 37 miles or 60 kilometers long.

Imagine driving down a highway one day, only to find the road has dropped into a jagged canyon the next, that’s how abrupt it was. And this wasn’t really happening on the surface. Underground, a massive dike, a blade of magma slicing upward, forced its way through the crust. Picture molten rock like a fiery crowbar, prying apart solid stone as it rises. That dike injected itself between the plates, widening the rift by as much as eight meters in some places, almost overnight.

For scientists, it was both alarming and exhilarating. They had theorised that Africa was splitting, but here was the proof unfolding in real time. Teams rushed in to measure the fissure, track aftershocks and sample the fresh lava. For villagers living nearby though, it was a frightening reminder that their land is not stable ground at all. It’s the front line of Earth’s tectonic power.

But for geologists, the 2005 crack was part of a bigger pattern, evidence that something deeper is driving this system. Because if the surface can split open so quickly, then what hidden force is pushing magma upward with such relentless energy? To answer that, we have to descend into the depths of the Earth, where a colossal plume of heat and molten rock pulses like the heartbeat of the planet.
Down here, the world is alien. Rock is solid, yes, but under crushing pressure and immense heat, it flows like tar. Rising through this mantle is something extraordinary, a plume of hot material.

A slow-motion blowtorch pressed against the base of Africa. For tens of millions of years, it has softened the crust and primed it for the split we see today. But here’s the remarkable part, it doesn’t rise steadily, it pulses. Like a kinked garden hose, pressure builds, then surges through. The Afar plume works the same way, sending bursts of heat and magma upward. Each surge forces the crust to bulge, crack and sometimes tear open, as it did dramatically in 2005.

So how do we know this isn’t just theory? Earth leaves clues. Seismic tomography, essentially an ultrasound of the planet, shows slow seismic waves beneath Afar, the hallmark of hotter, softer rock. Lava chemistry adds detail, some samples contain isotopes that trace back to astonishing depths, perhaps near the core-mantle boundary. That means it’s connected to Earth’s deepest reservoirs. And even satellites can see the pulse. GPS stations measure the land, drifting apart by millimetres each year.

Some areas rise, others sink, as though the surface itself is breathing. Put it all together and the message is clear. The Afar region is the visible edge of a deep living underground engine reshaping a continent. But deep plumes and seismic scans can feel abstract. What about the things we can actually see? The volcanoes, the fissures, the trembling ground beneath our feet. What does all this look like on the surface? In Afar, the signs are everywhere.  Volcanoes rise from the desert floor, some belching steam, others lying quiet but draped in fresh black lava that flowed only decades or centuries ago. Each cone, each crater, each lava field is a marker of the plume’s heartbeat breaking through.

Then there are the rocks themselves. Geologists collect shards of cooled lava, pumice and volcanic ash. Inside are minerals that act like time capsules recording the pressure, temperature and depth where the magma formed. Analysing them is like reading the diary of the Earth’s interior, evidence that matches what seismic scans suggest below.

The ground is restless too. Networks of seismometers pick up hundreds of tiny earthquakes each year. Most are too small for people to notice, but together they reveal the constant cracking and shifting of the crust.  And then there’s the slow reshaping of the land. GPS receivers bolted into bedrock show the rift widening by millimetres every year. It doesn’t sound like much, about the speed your fingernails grow, but scaled up over centuries it’s enough to split valleys, tilt lakes and reshape entire landscapes.

Even satellite images show Afar is sagging downward, as though the ground is being pried apart from below. All of these clues tell the same story. The pulses rising from the deep mantle are leaving fingerprints at the surface. Volcanoes mark the exits, rocks hold the recipes, and earthquakes whisper the stress building below.

But if the land keeps stretching, if valleys keep sinking, what happens when the cracks finally reach the ocean? At some point the land in Afar will drop low enough for water to rush in. The Red Sea or even the Gulf of Aden will spill inland, flooding the rift valley and creating a brand new ocean basin. Imagine standing where desert now stretches for miles and seeing waves rolling in, forming an entirely new coastline.

Geologists believe this is Africa’s future. The continent will split in two. On one side, most of Africa. On the other, a new landmass carrying parts of Ethiopia, Somalia and the Horn of Africa. Between them, a young ocean slowly widening year by year. The timeline? That’s the tricky part. Some models suggest it could happen within tens of thousands of years. Others say hundreds of thousands.

In geological terms though, that’s the blink of an eye. And if the 2005 crack taught us anything, it’s that the process doesn’t always move slowly. Sometimes change comes in sudden leaps. We’ve seen this kind of transformation before. The Atlantic Ocean itself began as a rift, much like Afar when South America pulled away from Africa. What was once dry land fractured, dropped and then flooded, becoming the ocean we know today.

So Afar may be offering us a rare window into the birth of an ocean. One day, future maps might show a blue gulf where today there is desert, reshaping trade routes, ecosystems and even climate. It may sound distant, but Africa’s split is a chapter in Earth’s ongoing story. A story that connects continents, climates and, ultimately, us.

So why does this matter beyond Africa? Because the forces tearing at Afar don’t stop at national borders. They ripple outward.When rifts move, they generate earthquakes that can devastate nearby communities. When volcanoes erupt, they throw ash and gases into the atmosphere, disrupting air travel and even shifting global climate. A single large eruption in East Africa could cool the planet for months.

And then there’s the human side. Millions of people live along this rift system, their farmland. Homes and water supplies depend on stable ground that is anything but stable. When a crack opens across a road or a village, it is a direct threat to daily life. But there are opportunities hidden in the danger. Rift zones are rich in geothermal energy, a clean and powerful resource drawn directly from Earth’s heat. Understanding how the rift works could help countries across East Africa tap into that energy safely.

But as much as Africa’s rift may feel unique, it’s really one chapter in a much bigger book. Earth is splitting in other places too, right now. Take Iceland. There, the Mid-Atlantic Ridge runs right across the island where the North American and Eurasian plates are drifting apart. You can actually walk through rift valleys in Tinkvetlir National Park, one foot on each continent.  Volcanic eruptions, geothermal energy and even hot water geysers all stem from the same process that is reshaping Africa.

And there are hints elsewhere too. The basin and range region of the western United States is being stretched, its valleys and mountain chains formed by crust under tension. But here’s where things get interesting for my viewers in the US. The Gulf of California, already an active rift, is creeping slowly northward toward this region. Some geologists believe the rift could eventually extend into the basin and range, carrying seawater into what is now dry land.

In geologic terms, Arizona itself could one day sit on the edge of a brand new ocean basin. Seen this way, Africa’s rift isn’t an isolated curiosity. It’s part of a cycle that has shaped our planet for billions of years. Continents assembling, breaking, drifting and colliding again. Afar just happens to be one of the rare places where we can watch this grand cycle unfold in real time. And that’s what makes it so extraordinary.

Usually the birth of oceans and the shattering of continents are events we only read in the rocks, long after they’ve happened. In Afar, the story is unfolding as we live and breathe. Cracks open, volcanoes erupt, valleys sink. All small steps in a process that will eventually redraw the map of the world. For us, bound by lifespans measured in decades, it’s easy to forget how fast this planet moves on its own clock.
A thousand years is ancient history to us. Yet to the Earth it is barely a heartbeat. We will never see the day Africa finally splits or the new ocean that will flood its deserts, but knowing it is happening gives us perspective. It reminds us that our lives are brief, fragile flashes set against deep time.

And yet for this moment we are witnesses to Earth in motion, sometimes slow and silent, sometimes in sudden, spectacular bursts. One of those bursts left a mystery behind. On the shores of Tonga, a massive boulder sits high on a cliff, too heavy for humans to move, too far inland to be simply washed ashore. So what force was powerful enough to throw it there? Find out in this video.

 

October 2026 Surprise: ENSO and NH Spike SSTs Warming

The best context for understanding decadal temperature changes comes from the world’s sea surface temperatures (SST), for several reasons:

  • The ocean covers 71% of the globe and drives average temperatures;
  • SSTs have a constant water content, (unlike air temperatures), so give a better reading of heat content variations;
  • A major El Nino was the dominant climate feature in recent years.

Previously I used HadSST3 for these reports, but Hadley Centre has made HadSST4 the priority, and v.3 will no longer be updated.  Reports since February are based on HadSST 4, but with a twist. The data is slightly different in the new version, 4.2.0.0 replacing 4.1.1.0. Product page is here.

The Current Context

The chart below shows SST monthly anomalies as reported in HadSST 4.2 starting in 2015 through October 2026. A global cooling pattern is seen clearly in the Tropics since its peak in 2016, joined by NH and SH cycling downward since 2016, followed by rising temperatures in 2023 and 2024 and cooling in 2025.  And now in 2026 comes a steadily rising Global spike from 0.8C in January to 1.2C in October, led by ENSO (Tropical) and NH, the latter exceeding slightly the previous peak in 2023.

To enlarge, open image in new tab.

Note that in 2015-2016 the Tropics and SH peaked in between two summer NH spikes.  That pattern repeated in 2019-2020 with a lesser Tropics peak and SH bump, but with higher NH spikes. By end of 2020, cooler SSTs in all regions took the Global anomaly well below the mean for this period.  A small warming was driven by NH summer peaks in 2021-22, but offset by cooling in SH and the tropics, By January 2023 the global anomaly was again below the mean.

Then comes a third iteration of the pattern starting in 2023 and continuing through October 2026. Each year presents a summer NH warming spike with the highest in 2023, now exceeded by 2026. The Tropics have a different rhythm, rising dramatically in 2023, peaking in 2024, then rapidly declining hitting bottom end of 2025. Now in 2026 ENSO is returning with a spike raising temperatures in all regions pulling the Global anomaly upward.  Note that all anomalies, Global, NH, SH, and Tropical are currently at their highest points.

Comment:

The climatists have seized on this unusual warming as proof their Zero Carbon agenda is needed, without addressing how impossible it would be for CO2 warming the air to raise ocean temperatures.  It is the ocean that warms the air, not the other way around.  Recently Steven Koonin had this to say about the phonomenon confirmed in the graph above:

El Nino is a phenomenon in the climate system that happens once every four or five years.  Heat builds up in the equatorial Pacific to the west of Indonesia and so on.  Then when enough of it builds up it surges across the Pacific and changes the currents and the winds.  As it surges toward South America it was discovered and named in the 19th century  It iswell understood at this point that the phenomenon has nothing to do with CO2.

Now people talk about changes in that phenomena as a result of CO2 but it’s there in the climate system already and when it happens it influences weather all over the world.   We feel it when it gets rainier in Southern California for example.  So for the last 3 years we have been in the opposite of an El Nino, a La Nina, part of the reason people think the West Coast has been in drought.

It has now shifted in the last months to an El Nino condition that warms the globe and is thought to contribute to this Spike we have seen. But there are other contributions as well.  One of the most surprising ones is that back in January of 2022 an enormous underwater volcano went off in Tonga and it put up a lot of water vapor into the upper atmosphere. It increased the upper atmosphere of water vapor by about 10 percent, and that’s a warming effect, and it may be that is contributing to why the spike is so high.

A longer view of SSTs

To enlarge, open image in new tab.

The graph above is noisy, but the density is needed to see the seasonal patterns in the oceanic fluctuations.  Previous posts focused on the rise and fall of the last El Nino starting in 2015.  This post adds a longer view, encompassing the significant 1998 El Nino and since.  The color schemes are retained for Global, Tropics, NH and SH anomalies.  Despite the longer time frame, I have kept the monthly data (rather than yearly averages) because of interesting shifts between January and July. 1995 is a reasonable (ENSO neutral) starting point prior to the first El Nino.

The sharp Tropical rise peaking in 1998 was dominant in the record, starting Jan. ’97 to pull up SSTs uniformly before returning to the same level Jan. ’99. There were strong cool periods before and after the 1998 El Nino event. Then SSTs in all regions returned to the mean in 2001-2.

SSTS fluctuate around the mean until 2007, when another, smaller ENSO event occurs. There is cooling 2007-8,  a lower peak warming in 2009-10, following by cooling in 2011-12.  Again SSTs are average 2013-14.

Now a different pattern appears.  The Tropics cooled sharply to Jan 11, then rise steadily for 4 years to Jan 15, at which point the most recent major El Nino takes off.  But this time in contrast to ’97-’99, the Northern Hemisphere produces peaks every summer pulling up the Global average.  In fact, these NH peaks appear every July starting in 2003, growing stronger to produce 3 massive highs in 2014, 15 and 16.  NH July 2017 was only slightly lower, and a fifth NH peak still lower in Sept. 2018.

The highest summer NH peaks came in 2019 and 2020, only this time the Tropics and SH were offsetting rather adding to the warming. (Note: these are high anomalies on top of the highest absolute temps in the NH.)  Since 2014 SH has played a moderating role, offsetting the NH warming pulses. After September 2020 temps dropped off down until February 2021.  In 2021-22 there were again summer NH spikes, but in 2022 moderated first by cooling Tropics and SH SSTs, then in October to January 2023 by deeper cooling in NH and Tropics.

Then in starting in 2023 the Tropics flipped from below to well above average, while NH produced a summer peak extending into September higher than any previous year.  2024 and 2025 replicated summer peaks in the previous itertation.  Now in 2026 October is slightly higher than 2023.

What to make of all this? The patterns suggest that in addition to El Ninos in the Pacific driving the Tropic SSTs, something else is going on in the NH.  The obvious culprit is the North Atlantic, since I have seen this sort of pulsing before.  After reading some papers by David Dilley, I confirmed his observation of Atlantic pulses into the Arctic every 8 to 10 years.

Contemporary AMO Observations

Through January 2023 I depended on the Kaplan AMO Index (not smoothed, not detrended) for N. Atlantic observations. But it is no longer being updated, and NOAA says they don’t know its future.  So I find that ERSSTv5 AMO dataset has current data.  It differs from Kaplan, which reported average absolute temps measured in N. Atlantic.  “ERSST5 AMO  follows Trenberth and Shea (2006) proposal to use the NA region EQ-60°N, 0°-80°W and subtract the global rise of SST 60°S-60°N to obtain a measure of the internal variability, arguing that the effect of external forcing on the North Atlantic should be similar to the effect on the other oceans.”  So the values represent SST anomaly differences between the N. Atlantic and the Global ocean.

The chart above confirms what Kaplan also showed.  As August is the hottest month for the N. Atlantic, its variability, high and low, drives the annual results for this basin.  Note also the peaks in 2010, lows after 2014, and a rise in 2021. Then in 2023 the peak reached 1.4C before declining to 0.8, and now back up to 1.2C August 2026.  An annual chart below is informative:

Note the difference between blue/green years, beige/brown, and purple/red years.  2010, 2021, 2022 all peaked strongly in August or September.  1998 and 2007 were mildly warm.  2016 and 2018 were matching or cooler than the global average.  2023 started out slightly warm, then rose steadily to an  extraordinary peak in July.  August to October were only slightly lower, but by December cooled by ~0.4C.

Then in 2024 the AMO anomaly started higher than any previous year, then leveled off for two months declining slightly into April.  Remarkably, May showed an upward leap putting this on a higher track than 2023, and rising slightly higher in June.  In July, August and September 2024 the anomaly declined, and despite a small rise in October, ended close to where it began.

Note 2025 started much lower than the previous year and headed sharply downward, well below the previous two years, and since April through September aligning with 2010. In October there was an unusual upward spike, now reversed down to match 2022 and 2016.  The orange 2026 line started downward and is visible on top of 2016 purple line, then slightly higher. Now 2026 is spiking higher in July and August up to 1.2C and holding there in September and October.

The pattern suggests the ocean may be demonstrating a stairstep pattern like that we have also seen in HadCRUT4.

The purple line is the average anomaly 1980-1996 inclusive, value 0.18.  The orange line the average 1980-2026, value 0.42 also for the period 1996-2013. The pink line is 2013-2022, value 0.65. The red line is 2022-2026, value 0.92. As noted above, these rising stages are driven by the combined warming in the Tropics and NH, including both Pacific and Atlantic basins.

Curiosity:  Solar Coincidence?

The news about our current solar cycle 25 is that the solar activity is hitting peak numbers now and higher  than expected 1-2 years in the future.  As livescience put it:  Solar maximum could hit us harder and sooner than we thought. How dangerous will the sun’s chaotic peak be?  Some charts from spaceweatherlive look familar to these sea surface temperature charts.

 

Summary

The oceans are driving the warming this century.  SSTs took a step up with the 1998 El Nino and have stayed there with help from the North Atlantic, and more recently the Pacific northern “Blob.”  The ocean surfaces are releasing a lot of energy, warming the air, but eventually will have a cooling effect.  The decline after 1937 was rapid by comparison, so one wonders: How long can the oceans keep this up? And is the sun adding forcing to this process?

uss-pearl-harbor-deploys-global-drifter-buoys-in-pacific-ocean

USS Pearl Harbor deploys Global Drifter Buoys in Pacific Ocean

Sabine Exposes Event Attribution Fake Math

In a previous post below Patrick Brown provides a deeper dive into this charade to enable a legal shakedown.

Devious Climate Attribution Studies

Patrick Brown raises the question Do Climate Attribution Studies Tell the Full Story? Excerpts in italics with my bolds and added images, his analysis concluding thusly:

How a cascade of selection effects bias
the collective output of extreme event attribution studies.

Weather and climate extremes—such as high temperatures, floods, droughts, tropical cyclones, extratropical cyclones, and severe thunderstorms—have always threatened both human and natural systems. Given their significant impacts, there is considerable interest in how human-caused climate change influences these extremes. This is the focus of the relatively new discipline of Extreme Event Attribution (EEA).

Over the past couple of decades, there has been an explosion in EEA studies focusing on (or, “triggered by”) some prior notable weather or climate extreme. Non-peer-reviewed reports from World Weather Attribution (e.g., here, here, and here) represent some of the most notable examples of these kinds of analyses, and many similar studies also populate the peer-reviewed literature. The Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society’s “Explaining Extreme Events From a Climate Perspective” annual series compiles such studies, as does the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, and they are also synthesized in reports like those from the IPCC (IPCC WG1 AR6 Chapter 11.2.3) and the United States National Climate Assessment.

The collective output of these kinds of studies certainly gives the impression that human-caused climate change is drastically changing the frequency and intensity of all kinds of weather extremes. Indeed, Carbon Brief recently published an extensive summary of the science of EEA studies, which begins with the proclamation, “As global temperatures rise, extreme weather events are becoming more intense and more frequent all around the world.”

However, these numbers cannot be taken as an accurate quantification of the influence of climate change on extreme weather because they are heavily influenced by a cascade of selection biases originating from the physical climate system, as well as researcher and media incentives. Identifying and understanding these biases is a prerequisite for properly interpreting the collective output of EEA studies and, thus, what implications they hold for general scientific understanding, as well as political and legal questions.

The large apparent discrepancy between the size of the influence of human-caused climate change on extreme weather reported in EEA studies (like those compiled by Carbon Brief) compared to more comprehensive systematic analyses (like those compiled by the IPCC) can, in large part, be attributed to the many layers of Selection Biases that influence the EEA literature’s collective output.

Selection Bias is a broad term that refers to any bias that arises from a process that selects data for analysis in a way that fails to ensure that data is representative of the broader population that the study wishes to describe.

Selection biases in the context of EEA studies include those associated with the physical climate system itself, those concerning proclivities and incentives facing researchers/journals, and those concerning the proclivities and incentives facing the media. They include

Occurrence Bias is a bias introduced by the physical climate system. Since EEA studies tend to be triggered by extreme events that have actually occurred, there is reason to believe that these studies will disproportionately sample events that are more likely than average to be exacerbated by climate change because the events occurred in the first place. Essentially, extreme events that are more likely to occur under climate change—and thus more likely to be observed—are going to be overrepresented in EEA studies, and extreme events that are less likely to occur under climate change—and thus less likely to be observed—are going to be underrepresented in EEA studies.

The map below illustrates this phenomenon. It shows changes in the magnitude of extreme drought under climate change. Specifically, it shows the fractional change in the intensity of once-per-50-year droughts (as quantified by monthly soil moisture) between a preindustrial and 21st-century run (SSP2-4.5 emissions) of the highly-regarded NCAR CESM2 Climate Model. Blue areas represent locations where the model simulates that extreme droughts become less frequent and intense with enhanced greenhouse gas concentrations, and red areas represent locations where the model simulates that extreme droughts become more frequent and intense with enhanced greenhouse gas concentrations. It is notable that overall, this model simulates that warming decreases the frequency and intensity of extreme drought in more locations than it increases it (consistent with soil moistening under warming simulated by other models).

Now, here’s the kicker: The black dots show locations where once-per-50-year droughts actually occurred in the 21st-century simulation and thus represent events that would plausibly trigger EEA studies.

What do you notice about where the dots are compared to where the red is? That’s right; the simulated EEA studies overwhelmingly sample areas where droughts are getting more intense and more frequent by the very nature that those are the types of droughts that are more likely to occur in the warming climate. The result is that the EEA sample is majorly biased: warming decreased the intensity of once-per-50-year droughts by about 1% overall, but it increased their intensity within the EEA sample by 18%!

Thus, if you just relied on the EEA sample, you would come away with an
incorrect impression not only on the magnitude of change in extreme droughts
but also on the sign of the direction of change!

Choice Bias arises when researchers use prior knowledge to choose events for EEA studies that are more likely to have been made more severe by climate change. A clear example of Choice Bias pervading the Carbon Brief database is there have been 3.6 times more studies on extreme heat than there have been on extreme winter weather (205 vs. 57). Another example would be the dearth of EEA studies on extratropical cyclones (the kinds of low-pressure systems with cold and warm fronts that are responsible for most of the dramatic weather outside of the tropics). The IPCC states that the number of extratropical cyclones associated with intense surface wind speeds is expected to decrease strongly in the Northern Hemisphere with warming. Yet, it is relatively rare for EEA attribution studies to be done on these types of systems, which results in an exclusion of this good news from the EEA literature.

Publication Bias could be playing a role, too, where researchers are more likely to submit, and journals are likely to publish studies that report significant effects on salient events compared to studies that find null effects.

From Clark et al., 2023

Finally, the climate reporting media ecosystem is characterized by actors whose explicit mission is to raise awareness of the negative impacts of climate change, and thus, there will be a natural Media Coverage Bias with a tendency to selectively highlight EEA studies where climate change is found to be a larger driver than EEA studies that do not reach such a conclusion. These selection biases are apparent at the aggregate level, but there is also strong evidence of their presence in individual studies.

A more recent specific example suggestive of many of these dynamics is a study, Gilford et al. (2024), titled “Human-caused ocean warming has intensified recent hurricanes”. This study was conducted by three researchers at Climate Central, which summarizes the study’s findings with the following infographic:

From Climate Central press release on Gilford et al. (2024).

Essentially, they claim that climate change is enhancing the intensity of all hurricanes and that the enhancement is quite large: Storms today are calculated to be an entire Category stronger than they would have been in a preindustrial climate.

This is a huge effect, and thus, if it were real, it is reasonable to expect to see clear long-term trends in metrics of tropical cyclone (hurricane) intensity like the accumulated number of major (Category 3+) hurricane days or the accumulated cyclone energy from all tropical cyclones (which is proportional to the square of hurricane windspeed accumulated over their lifetimes). However, any long-term trends in such metrics are subtle at best, both globally and over the North Atlantic.

From Colorado State University Department of Atmospheric Science Tropical Meteorology Project.

So, this is a microcosm of the aforementioned apparent discrepancy between more broad quantifications of changes in extremes and their associated EEA counterparts, and again, I’d argue there are several selection biases at play affecting the production and dissemination of the EEA study.

Let’s start with Choice Bias on methodology. Human-caused warming changes the environment in some ways that work to enhance hurricanes and in other ways that diminish them. The main way that hurricanes are enhanced is via the increase in sea surface temperatures (which provides the fundamental fuel for hurricanes), and the main way that hurricanes are diminished is via changes in atmospheric wind shear and humidity.

The net result of these countervailing factors pulling in opposite directions is that we expect fewer hurricanes overall, but when hurricanes are able to form, they can be stronger than they would otherwise. These factors, though, are small relative to natural random variability, and thus, they are difficult to detect in observations.

However, the Climate Central researchers made the methodological choice
to largely exclude the influence of factors that diminish
hurricane development from the study.

Are these Choice Biases in event type and methodology an accident? There are many reasons to believe they are not.

The research paper itself spells out that the motivation of the study is to “connect the dots” between climate change and hurricanes because “landfalling hurricanes with high intensities—can act as ‘focusing events’ that draw public attention” and that “Increased attention during and in wake of storms creates opportunities for public and private discourse around climate and disaster preparedness.”

Then, there is the extensive media coverage of this study. It was picked up by 134 news outlets and ranked in the 99.95th percentile of research articles (across all journals) of similar age in terms of online attention. Further, it was immediately incorporated into seven Wikipedia articles (likely having high leverage on AI queries, which would make its findings indistinguishable from scientific “fact”). This is affected by the aforementioned Media Coverage Bias, but it is also undoubtedly directly influenced by the efforts of Climate Central, which is explicitly an advocacy organization whose self-described specialty is media placement and dissemination. 

The above sheds light on the reasons for certain choice biases in a particular study, but there is plenty of evidence that these selection biases are pervasive in the EEA field. After all, Dr. Myles Allen essentially founded the field with the motivation of answering the question, “Will it ever be possible to sue anyone for damaging the climate?”. This same motivation seems to animate many of the most high-profile scientists in the field today, like Allen’s protege, Dr. Friederike Otto (co-founder and leader of World Weather Attribution). She and her organization are frequently cited as bringing the necessary intellectual authority to credibly sue fossil fuel companies. She states the motivation of her work explicitly:

“Attributing extreme weather events to climate change, as I do
through my work as a climatologist, means we can hold
countries and companies to account for their inaction.”

Given the explicitly stated motivation of those in the EEA field, it is quite reasonable to suppose that there are major selection biases at play, and thus, it is not at all surprising that the collective output of the EEA field would look so different from more broad comprehensive assessments.

See Also X-Weather Attributions by Pseudo-Scientists

 

 

Facts on Climate Change Costs, Trade-offs and Results

Dr. Bjørn Lomborg and Fraser Institute have published a series of essays with evidence regarding policies intended to mitigate climate change. Excerpts below with links to papers supporting the following conclusions.

Climate Change: A Fact-Based Assessment of Costs, Trade-Offs, and Results is a new multimedia research and educational project by the Fraser Institute in collaboration with Dr. Bjørn Lomborg’s Copenhagen Consensus. It offers Canadians a data-driven analysis of the real risks posed by climate change, and measures the substantial costs and trade-offs that accompany many climate policies.

Electricity prices across Canada up 88% since 2000,
slowing
economic growth and denying
Canadians greater prosperity

The essays include:

  • Climate Change Is One Policy Concern Among Many: Canadians, like people everywhere, confront a multitude of pressing challenges: soaring housing costs, strained health care, opioid crises, and economic insecurity amid global turbulence. Climate change is undeniably one issue among many—but after years of apocalyptic warnings that the world is about to end, or that rising temperatures signal imminent, irreversible doom, the public is tuning out.

  • We Are Hyping Up Rising Heat Deaths, but Ignoring Declining Cold Deaths: While rising temperatures explain a 6.0 per cent increase in heat deaths globally, deaths from cold have declined 40 per cent because of rising temperatures.

  • No, the Planet Is Not on Fire: In the early 2000s, roughly three percent of the world’s land surface burned annually, but by 2022, only 2.17 per cent burned, and in 2025, it was 2.2 per cent.

  • Are Natural Disasters Increasing Because of Climate Change?: Once we correct for population increases and increased wealth over time, the data show a clear decreasing trend in both human and economic vulnerability from natural disasters, with global average mortality down 6.5 times and economic loss rates declining five times from 1980–1989 to 2007–2016.

  • Despite Alarmist Claims, We’re Actually Growing More Food Than Ever Before: Since 1990, the average number of children dying from malnutrition has declined dramatically from 6.5 million to 2.5 million each year. The World Health Organization expects the decline to continue—even with climate change—with annual deaths projected to halve once again by 2050.

  • Wind and Solar Power Are Unreliable and Therefore Expensive: The more a country relies on solar and wind, the higher electricity prices become for both households and businesses. In nations with little or no solar and wind, the weighted average price sits around 16 Canadian cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh). For every additional 10 percentage points of solar and wind in the electricity mix, prices rise by slightly more than three cents.

  • Electric Cars Do Little for the Climate: Manufacturing EVs generates emissions—especially producing the battery—which requires a large amount of energy, mostly achieved with coal in China. Just as importantly, the carbon footprint of an electric vehicle depends heavily on how the electricity used to charge it is produced.

  • The Reality of the Energy Transition: Not Happening: Over the past half-century, the global energy produced from oil and coal has doubled, while hydro power has tripled, and gas has quadrupled, all the while there’s been an explosion in the use of nuclear, solar and wind.

  • Abundant, Affordable Energy Is Key to Economic Growth and Prosperity: A 10 per cent increase in energy prices reduced economic growth by about 0.15 percentage points over the 1960 to 2016 period, and yet, across Canada energy prices have increased 88 per cent nationwide since 2000.

  • Climate Policy Fixation Blinds Us to Solutions That Actually Improve Human Lives: Instead of reducing emissions in high-income countries, which at best would slow global temperature increases by 0.1 degree Celsius by 2100, people in developing countries would benefit much more from programs to combat diseases, improve nutrition, and improve education.

Explore the Climate Change Essays

Related Article Financial Post Nov. 3 Climate change is a problem—not the end of the world

 

 

Advance Briefing for COP31 Türkiye 2026

Overview from Irish Times ‘Going for the vibes’: Cop31 climate summit expectations ‘pretty much zero’   Excerpts in italics with my bolds and added images.

Global and domestic political difficulties overshadow the annual
negotiations at this year’s summit, co-hosted by Australia and Turkey

The signal from the organisers of this year’s summit, Australia and Turkey, who are co-hosting because neither country would withdraw its bid to stage the event, which begins next week. Turkey’s climate minister, Murat Kurum:

“We want to create a Cop31 that prioritises action and implementation, where commitments are finally put into practice.”
“Cop31 is an implementation Cop and we should focus on that.” Ireland’s climate minister, Darragh O’Brien.

It is true there have been many commitments that have yet to be honoured in full, or even in part.  They include the Paris Agreement from Cop21, the creation of the Loss and Damage Fund from Cop27 and agreement to transition away from fossil fuels from Cop28.  All were breakthrough achievements but much work is required to realise their goals.

Other recent pledges came without instructions as to how to proceed and have been slow to progress:

♦  to triple renewable capacity by 2030,
♦  double energy efficiency and
♦  scale up climate finance.

There is one new buzz word around this year’s summit, however – electrification. Turkey and Australia want a Cop31 agreement that commits to having 35 per cent of global demand for power, heat and transport supplied by electricity by 2035. The idea behind the “35 by 35” goal is that it will kick-start the transition away from fossil fuels.

“A lot is being made of this electrification target,”  “The key thing, though, is that it doesn’t seem to include a commitment to clean energy,” says Diarmuid Torney of Dublin City University.

It certainly doesn’t sound like much of a win if electric cars replace petrol and electric heating replaces coal but the electricity itself is generated by burning gas.

With a so far underwhelming agenda, Cop31 might be considered less of a draw than previous summits but the number of delegates accredited and pavilions booked by countries, alliances and industries is touching a record high.  Prof Peter Thorne of the Icarus climate research centre at Maynooth University despairs of this burgeoning sideshow element to the negotiations.

“Cops have become an absolute circus,” he says. “Many will be going to network or for the vibes with no official role and at best talking to 20 mates in some country pavilion.”

“There will be inevitable window dressing applied and positive words, but the fundamental issues will remain,” he says.

“A lack of ambition amongst even the handful of states with the means to progress reductions emissions, a growing adaptation gap even in developed countries, and yawning finance, equity and justice gaps.”

My Comments

Since there is a big push on climate funding, maybe they could get to the bottom of this.

Maybe donors are put off by no one knowing who gets the money and for what it is spent.  And while they are investigating, how about understanding Energy Return on Investment (EROI): you know, the notion that an energy project is worth doing if the energy produced is greater than energy spent.  “Electrify everything” is only people dreaming of a world free of fossil fuels.

Why a COP Briefing?

Actually, climate hysteria is like a seasonal sickness.  Each year a contagion of anxiety and fear is created by disinformation going viral in both legacy and social media in the run up to the annual autumnal COP.  Since the climatists are especially desperate with the US outspokenly against the climate movement, we can expect the public will be hugely hosed with alarms over the next few weeks.  Before the distress signals go full tilt, individuals need to inoculate themselves against the false claims, in order to build some herd immunity against the nonsense the media will promulgate. This post is offered as a means to that end.

Media Climate Hype is a Cover Up

Back in 2015 in the run up to Paris COP, French mathematicians published a thorough critique of the raison d’etre of the whole crusade. They said:

Fighting Global Warming is Absurd, Costly and Pointless.

  • Absurd because of no reliable evidence that anything unusual is happening in our climate.
  • Costly because trillions of dollars are wasted on immature, inefficient technologies that serve only to make cheap, reliable energy expensive and intermittent.
  • Pointless because we do not control the weather anyway.

The prestigious Société de Calcul Mathématique (Society for Mathematical Calculation) issued a detailed 195-page White Paper presenting a blistering point-by-point critique of the key dogmas of global warming. The synopsis with links to the entire document is at COP Briefing for Realists

Even without attending to their documentation, you can tell they are right because all the media climate hype is concentrated against those three points.

Finding: Nothing unusual is happening with our weather and climate.
Hype: Every metric or weather event is “unprecedented,” or “worse than we thought.”

Finding: Proposed solutions will cost many trillions of dollars for little effect or benefit.
Hype: Zero carbon will lead the world to do the right thing.  Anyway, the planet must be saved at any cost.

Finding: Nature operates without caring what humans do or think.
Hype: Any destructive natural event is blamed on humans burning fossil fuels.

How the Media Throws Up Flak to Defend False Suppositions

The Absurd Media:  Climate is Dangerous Today, Yesterday It was Ideal.

Billions of dollars have been spent researching any and all negative effects from a warming world: Everything from Acne to Zika virus.  A recent Climate Report repeats the usual litany of calamities to be feared and avoided by submitting to IPCC demands. The evidence does not support these claims. An example:

 It is scientifically established that human activities produce GHG emissions, which accumulate in the atmosphere and the oceans, resulting in warming of Earth’s surface and the oceans, acidification of the oceans, increased variability of climate, with a higher incidence of extreme weather events, and other changes in the climate.

Moreover, leading experts believe that there is already more than enough excess heat in the climate system to do severe damage and that 2C of warming would have very significant adverse effects, including resulting in multi-meter sea level rise.

Experts have observed an increased incidence of climate-related extreme weather events, including increased frequency and intensity of extreme heat and heavy precipitation events and more severe droughts and associated heatwaves. Experts have also observed an increased incidence of large forest fires; and reduced snowpack affecting water resources in the western U.S. The most recent National Climate Assessment projects these climate impacts will continue to worsen in the future as global temperatures increase.

Alarming Weather and Wildfires

But: Weather is not more extreme.


And Wildfires were worse in the past.
But: Sea Level Rise is not accelerating.

post-glacial_sea_level

Litany of Changes

Seven of the ten hottest years on record have occurred within the last decade; wildfires are at an all-time high, while Arctic Sea ice is rapidly diminishing.

We are seeing one-in-a-thousand-year floods with astonishing frequency.

When it rains really hard, it’s harder than ever.

We’re seeing glaciers melting, sea level rising.

The length and the intensity of heatwaves has gone up dramatically.

Plants and trees are flowering earlier in the year. Birds are moving polewards.

We’re seeing more intense storms.

But: Arctic Ice has not declined since 2007.

But: All of these are within the range of past variability.In fact our climate is remarkably stable, compared to the range of daily temperatures during a year where I live.

And many aspects follow quasi-60 year cycles.

The Impractical Media:  Money is No Object in Saving the Planet.

Here it is blithely assumed that the UN can rule the seas to stop rising, heat waves to cease, and Arctic ice to grow (though why we would want that is debatable).  All this will be achieved by leaving fossil fuels in the ground and powering civilization with windmills and solar panels.  While admitting that our way of life depends on fossil fuels, they ignore the inadequacy of renewable energy sources at their present immaturity.

An Example:
The choice between incurring manageable costs now and the incalculable, perhaps even irreparable, burden Youth Plaintiffs and Affected Children will face if Defendants fail to rapidly transition to a non-fossil fuel economy is clear. While the full costs of the climate damages that would result from maintaining a fossil fuel-based economy may be incalculable, there is already ample evidence concerning the lower bound of such costs, and with these minimum estimates, it is already clear that the cost of transitioning to a low/no carbon economy are far less than the benefits of such a transition. No rational calculus could come to an alternative conclusion. Defendants must act with all deliberate speed and immediately cease the subsidization of fossil fuels and any new fossil fuel projects, and implement policies to rapidly transition the U.S. economy away from fossil fuels.

But CO2 relation to Temperature is Inconsistent.

But: The planet is greener because of rising CO2.

But: Modern nations (G20) depend on fossil fuels for nearly 90% of their energy.

But: Renewables are not ready for prime time.

People need to know that adding renewables to an electrical grid presents both technical and economic challenges.  Experience shows that adding intermittent power more than 10% of the baseload makes precarious the reliability of the supply.  South Australia is demonstrating this with a series of blackouts when the grid cannot be balanced.  Germany got to a higher % by dumping its excess renewable generation onto neighboring countries until the EU finally woke up and stopped them. Texas got up to 29% by dumping onto neighboring states, and some like Georgia are having problems.

But more dangerous is the way renewables destroy the economics of electrical power.  Seasoned energy analyst Gail Tverberg writes:

In fact, I have come to the rather astounding conclusion that even if wind turbines and solar PV could be built at zero cost, it would not make sense to continue to add them to the electric grid in the absence of very much better and cheaper electricity storage than we have today. There are too many costs outside building the devices themselves. It is these secondary costs that are problematic. Also, the presence of intermittent electricity disrupts competitive prices, leading to electricity prices that are far too low for other electricity providers, including those providing electricity using nuclear or natural gas. The tiny contribution of wind and solar to grid electricity cannot make up for the loss of more traditional electricity sources due to low prices.

These issues are discussed in more detail in the post Climateers Tilting at Windmills

The Irrational Media:  Whatever Happens in Nature is Our Fault.

An Example:

Other potential examples include agricultural losses. Whether or not insurance
reimburses farmers for their crops, there can be food shortages that lead to higher food
prices (that will be borne by consumers, that is, Youth Plaintiffs and Affected Children).
There is a further risk that as our climate and land use pattern changes, disease vectors
may also move (e.g., diseases formerly only in tropical climates move northward).36 This
could lead to material increases in public health costs

But: Actual climate zones are local and regional in scope, and they show little boundary change.

But: Ice cores show that it was warmer in the past, not due to humans.

The hype is produced by computer programs designed to frighten and distract children and the uninformed.  For example, there was mention above of “multi-meter” sea level rise.  It is all done with computer models.  For example, below is San Francisco.  More at USCS Warnings of Coastal Floodings

In addition, there is no mention that GCMs projections are running about twice as hot as observations.

Omitted is the fact GCMs correctly replicate tropospheric temperature observations only when CO2 warming is turned off.

Figure 5. Simplification of IPCC AR5 shown above in Fig. 4. The colored lines represent the range of results for the models and observations. The trends here represent trends at different levels of the tropical atmosphere from the surface up to 50,000 ft. The gray lines are the bounds for the range of observations, the blue for the range of IPCC model results without extra GHGs and the red for IPCC model results with extra GHGs.The key point displayed is the lack of overlap between the GHG model results (red) and the observations (gray). The nonGHG model runs (blue) overlap the observations almost completely.

In the effort to proclaim scientific certainty, neither the media nor IPCC discuss the lack of warming since the 1998 El Nino, despite two additional El Ninos in 2010 and 2016, plus an unexplained spike in 2023-24, now cooling off.

Further they exclude comparisons between fossil fuel consumption and temperature changes. The legal methodology for discerning causation regarding work environments or medicine side effects insists that the correlation be strong and consistent over time, and there be no confounding additional factors. As long as there is another equally or more likely explanation for a set of facts, the claimed causation is unproven. Such is the null hypothesis in legal terms: Things happen for many reasons unless you can prove one reason is dominant.

Finally, advocates and IPCC are picking on the wrong molecule. The climate is controlled not by CO2 but by H20. Oceans make climate through the massive movement of energy involved in water’s phase changes from solid to liquid to gas and back again. From those heat transfers come all that we call weather and climate: Clouds, Snow, Rain, Winds, and Storms.

Esteemed climate scientist Richard Lindzen ended a very fine recent presentation with this description of the climate system:

I haven’t spent much time on the details of the science, but there is one thing that should spark skepticism in any intelligent reader. The system we are looking at consists in two turbulent fluids interacting with each other. They are on a rotating planet that is differentially heated by the sun. A vital constituent of the atmospheric component is water in the liquid, solid and vapor phases, and the changes in phase have vast energetic ramifications. The energy budget of this system involves the absorption and reemission of about 200 watts per square meter. Doubling CO2 involves a 2% perturbation to this budget. So do minor changes in clouds and other features, and such changes are common. In this complex multifactor system, what is the likelihood of the climate (which, itself, consists in many variables and not just globally averaged temperature anomaly) is controlled by this 2% perturbation in a single variable? Believing this is pretty close to believing in magic. Instead, you are told that it is believing in ‘science.’ Such a claim should be a tip-off that something is amiss. After all, science is a mode of inquiry rather than a belief structure.

Summary:  From this we learn three things:

Climate warms and cools without any help from humans.
Warming is good and cooling is bad.
The hypothetical warming from CO2 would be a good thing.