Tilak Doshi writes at Clintel Climate Mania Has Made the World Bank Stupid. Excerpts below in italics with my bolds and added images.
The World Bank was founded to promote economic growth in developing
countries but has joined the brigade fulminating against the weather gods.
The world’s poor deserve better than that.
As the faithful gather in Antalya for COP31, the World Bank laid its offering on the altar last week: Governance for Climate and Development, the fifth annual digest of its Country Climate and Development Reports (CCDRs) now covering 103 economies. One might have expected a chastened institution. In April 2025 US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told the Bretton Woods twins (World Bank and IMF) that mission creep had knocked them off course, and on June 29th this year the Bank duly retired its target of steering 45% of its financing to climate. Yet its own climate page still boasts of $48 billion in “climate co-benefits” in the last fiscal year, 44% of its own-account financing.
The target is dead. The mania – a form of climate-focused pathology – lives on.
The cart before the horse
The CCDR is the Bank’s “core diagnostic” for helping countries align their “climate ambitions” with their development priorities, and the Bank’s blog trails the new report as a journey from commitment to delivery. The phrasing smuggles in an equivalence that no finance minister in Lusaka or Abuja would recognise.
Why would a poor country have climate ambitions at all,
beyond ensuring that poverty does not stand between
its citizens and the travails of bad weather?
Is civilisation itself not born of the struggle against the depredations of nature? Is science, in the Baconian tradition, not power over a harsh nature, the taming of her furies for the comfort of man? The ambitions in question belong to the Net Zero ideologues of Brussels and Davos. The poor merely get to be the guinea pigs of climate modelling and Net Zero imperatives.
The Bank’s own text gives the game away. Its modelled losses are larger in poorer and hotter economies. Its headline adaptation case is Nigeria, where the projected GDP loss shrinks from 6.7% to about 1% once one assumes mechanisation, air conditioning, health interventions and flood-resilient investment. Heat stress, it notes, costs far less in high-income countries, where machines do the heavy lifting. Mauritius is declared at risk of water scarcity, yet 61% of the water its system captures is lost before it reaches a customer. That is a plumbing problem. Mechanisation, air conditioning and pipes that do not leak used to be called economic development. The Bank has rediscovered it and filed it under “climate adaptation”.

Unsurprisingly, the Bank finds that the poor, and poor women above all, suffer most in its scenarios. Some 1.5 billion people, it says, are exposed to climate hazards and highly vulnerable because they lack basic infrastructure, financial access or social protection. Because, that is, they are poor. The rich are spared by sturdier homes and higher living standards. Poverty is the root cause of deprivation whatever the weather throws at people, and it would remain so under the most benign climate imaginable. The remedy is growth, as development economists such as Jagdish Bhagwati have argued for decades. The record bears them out: global death rates from natural disasters have fallen by more than 90% over the past century, a century in which the planet warmed and humanity grew rich enough to cope.

From the finance ministry to ‘civil society’
How did a once competent institution arrive here? The late Deepak Lal, who served as the Bank’s research administrator in the mid-1980s, saw it coming. In a 2004 column he described the battle between the “old” Bank, whose advice was grounded in the classical liberal economics summarised as the Washington Consensus, and the new one fashioned under Sir James Wolfensohn, the ninth President of the World Bank, which embraced the NGOs’ ‘civil society’ agenda.
On one side stood finance ministries and trained economists; on the other, activists, aid ministries and UN agencies. To ask the two to split the difference, Lal wrote, was like asking a scientist who knows the earth is round to accommodate a man who believes it flat. Citing the eminent economist Anne Krueger, he observed that once private capital markets had opened to developing countries the Bank faced three choices: confine itself to the poorest countries, reinvent itself around ‘soft’ issues such as the environment and NGO engagement, or close down. Bureaucrats being bureaucrats, it chose the second. Lal recommended the third.
The new report shows the NGO mind in full possession of the building at 1818 H Street in Washington, D.C. Its governance chapter does not ask how poor countries might secure small government (to reduce propensities for corruption), secure property rights, sound money or cheap energy. It celebrates “framework laws” that turn climate targets into statutory obligations and “bind successive administrations”, noting with approval that more than 50 of its 103 economies have enacted or are preparing one. It advises that where climate branding meets resistance, energy access can offer a “more consensual framing”. It looks forward to “irreversible structural change”. Voters who might prefer cheaper electricity are a political-economy constraint to be managed. Britain, which pioneered this kind of legislation, now enjoys the highest electricity prices in the industrialised world. It is an odd export to press on poorer developing countries.
The same string of terrible ideas runs through the “low-emission pathways”, which propose an average 78.7% cut in emissions by 2050 for the countries modelled. Bulgaria, where the report admits nearly 30% of households were energy-poor in 2023 and where the exit from coal threatens 12,000 jobs at Maritsa East, is nonetheless walked down a path anchored in Net Zero by 2050. The modelled bill for all this “climate-smart development” averages 1.8% of GDP a year to 2030, and 11% in Fiji. Nigeria, we learn, received climate finance equal to about 8% of its estimated annual needs. Having invented the need, the Bank laments the gap.
Back to factory settings
The remedy is not complicated. The Bank should stop producing climate diagnostics and return to asking the question its founders set it: what stands between a country and sustained economic growth? The answers have not changed since Smith. Peace, easy taxes, tolerable justice, open trade and the cheapest reliable energy available will do more to protect a Gambian farmer or a Fijian fisherman from drought and storm than any number of framework laws and budget-tagging exercises. If the Bank cannot bring itself to say so, Lal’s third option remains on the table.

How half a billion people have risen out of extreme poverty in recent decades. Underlying and enabling everything: Access to affordable, reliable energy
.


