Lomborg: Net Zero Colossal Cost, Tiny Benefit

Bjorn Lomborg’s New York Post article is Colossal cost — and tiny benefit — of the ‘net zero’ climate madness.  Excerpts in italics with my bolds and added images.

Right now, thousands of diplomats, bureaucrats and campaigners are meeting in Türkiye yet again for the 31st United Nations climate summit.

The demand will be the one made repeatedly at previous conferences: net zero by 2050. What nobody will say is what that costs, or what it buys. In 30 summits, nobody has calculated the price versus the benefit. So I have.

I built NetZeroCostBenefit.com that lets anyone see what the United States, or any other country or group of countries, would achieve by reaching net zero in 2050, what it would cost, and what the climate benefit would be worth.

None of the inputs are mine: The climate model, MAGICC, is used throughout the UN’s own climate reports and can translate any country’s promised emissions cuts into lower temperatures by 2100. The costs come from the UN’s own surveys of economic models, and the damage estimates from the two most recent syntheses of the economics of warming.

Anyone can check the arithmetic, though few delegates in Antalya will want to.

For its latest report and updates, the climate panel gathered nearly a thousand model estimates of what climate policy costs. Almost none of them get anywhere near net zero by 2050, because it is so hard and costly. Only three models reach net zero starting from today’s actual emissions, rather than assuming cuts that began years ago.

They find that global net zero would cost between 3% and 19% of global GDP in 2050, because expensive energy throttles growth. My website uses the middle one, estimating a loss of 7.2% of GDP in 2050, measured from current policies.The benefits come from the two most recent syntheses of the damage from warming, by one of the most quoted climate economists, Richard Tol, and the other by William Nordhaus, the only climate economist to win the Nobel prize in economics. Given the warming the UN model projects under current policies, they find that climate change will cost the world 1.8% to 2.8% of GDP by 2100.

That is a real loss, but nowhere near the catastrophes bandied about. It is also a lot less than a 7.2% loss of GDP, and a lot further away. Moreover, net zero only avoids part of the damage.

Nor does one country’s effort buy much. If the United States reaches net zero in 2050 and stays there, the UN model says global temperature in 2100 would be 0.14°F lower. Nobody would notice.

Yet Americans would certainly notice the cost: by 2045 the annual cost would be $1.2 trillion a year. Over the century the cost adds up to $12.7 trillion in today’s money. The global climate benefit adds up to just under $2 trillion. The American sacrifice delivers 15 cents of benefits for every $1 spent.

Some will object that no country should look at its own numbers this way, because if everyone notices large costs but tiny benefits, nothing will get done. But a global deal that only works if nobody checks the numbers is not much of a deal. And the math doesn’t improve by pooling: the website shows that every nation ends up doing much less good for the world than what they put in.

Indeed, when you look at the whole world, global net zero by 2050 would avoid $24 trillion in climate damage this century but cost $255 trillion, both in today’s money. That’s 9 cents on the dollar.

The problem isn’t that countries act alone.
It’s that the policy itself costs more than it delivers.

Fossil fuels remain cheap and plentiful, despite price fluctuations. It is little wonder that they still supply more than four-fifths of global energy, and emissions rose again last year. At the pace of the past half-century, they won’t be gone by 2050. They’ll be gone a millennium later, in 2997.

There are much better ways to spend money than chasing “net zero,”
although most won’t be on the climate agenda at COP31.

The summit president has already made the August glacier flood in Nepal, which killed more than 1,400 people, his exhibit A: “If we want to understand the consequences of climate change, we need only look at Nepal.” Yet nothing agreed in Antalya will make the next flood measurably smaller. Early-warning systems and sturdier bridges would save far more Nepalese lives, far sooner, for far less money. Lifting people out of poverty, in Nepal and around the world, will make everyone less climate vulnerable and do far more good. None of these solutions costs anywhere near $255 trillion.

It doesn’t mean that climate change is harmless. But it means that net zero by 2050 is an egregiously bad buy. Across 30 climate summits, delegates have ignored that reality. Now anyone can run the numbers.

Bjorn Lomborg is President of the Copenhagen Consensus, Visiting Fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, and author of “False Alarm” and “Best Things First.”

Addendum:  Lomborg on the 21st century: cost-benefit analysis of climate policy

The yellow line shows the cost of climate policy (in trillions of dollars) as the limit of acceptable warming goes down. So the point at the bottom right of the graph shows that at zero policy cost, meaning if we do nothing, then according to Nordhaus’ model we will get warming of about 4.1 degrees by 2100. Whereas the upper left end of the yellow line shows that if we try to minimize warming we could get it down to about 2.2 degrees but it would cost $170 trillion doing so.

So if we go all in, we spend $170 trillion to avoid 1.8 degrees of warming.

Now to the orange line, which shows the estimated costs of the warming itself. If we keep warming to 2.2 degrees C, the models say the “social costs”, that is, the total losses humans will suffer, would be about $40 trillion, while if we get 4.1 degrees C warming the social costs will be about $140 trillion. Both figures are large, though bear in mind that they should be subtracted from what global GDP is estimated to reach in 2100, which will be enormous barring other catastrophes. But given these calculations, what should we do? From among the available policy choices, which is the best?

The key to figuring out the best option is to add the two costs together, that is, to pile the yellow line atop the orange one, which gives the black area in the chart. Its top line, unsurprisingly, drops initially as fairly cost-effective policies bring significant reductions in temperature increase, the famous picking of low-hanging fruit, and then turns back up as it gets harder and harder to reach more difficult results. And the point where it turns back up, it turns out, is at 3.5 degrees of warming, just a little below the 4 degrees we get from doing nothing. At which point we spend around $20 trillion total on climate policy.

If instead we try to stop the warming altogether, we fail, both in only holding it to 2.2° and in spending so much trying that we pile $170 trillion in policy costs atop $40 trillion in climate costs for a total bill of well over $200 trillion, which is not just worse than the optimum choice, it’s worse than doing nothing at all.

So our best bet is to prevent a bit of the warming, but only a little.
And if the models exaggerate either the warming or its costs,
that choice gets even better.

In fact Nordhaus’ model can be criticized for building in so much climate sensitivity that we get 4 C warming by 2100, which almost certainly is an overestimate. It can also be criticized for assuming politicians will implement efficient policies. Lomborg re-does the analysis under the assumption that policy costs are double the efficient level, and the result is the optimal target moves up to 3.75C, meaning we do even less.

Either way, the conclusion from a mainstream Nobel Prize-winning economic analysis based on mainstream assumptions about the science, rather than the claims of “deniers”, is that we aren’t going to stop warming no matter what we do, and that we shouldn’t try to go to Net Zero or anywhere close. Instead, most targets being talked about are worse than doing nothing, and the optimal policy path involves only modest efforts to reduce emissions over the 21st century. Which actually suggests that all those politicians talking a lot while doing very little are accidentally on the right course.

Summary:  Even taking the dubious assumption that fossil fuel CO2 causes global warming does not justify the costly attempt to reduce CO2 emissions down to net zero.

Leave a Reply